Skip to main content

Best pumpkin spice coffees

(Image credit: Heidi Kaden / Unsplash)

The taste and aroma of pumpkin spice coffees evoke a deep sense of warmth and comfort. While the exact ingredients of the flavor remain a mystery, we believe it's a delicious mix of cinnamon, nutmeg, allspices, and ginger. This delicate blend gives pumpkin spice it's signature warm undertone perfect for perking up your mornings and winding down chilly evenings. We have put together the best pumpkin coffees, so you never miss your daily caffeine fix.

Staff favorite

(Image credit: Amazon)

Starbucks pumpkin spice ground coffee

Where it all started

Starbucks introduced us to the comfort of pumpkin spice coffees, which has grown into an obsession. This blend of 100% arabica beans and carefully selected natural flavors offers authentic Starbucks coffee fresh at home. Maybe it’s the seasonal, limited availability that makes it so popular. Or perhaps it’s the fact that it’s made without artificial flavors. Whatever makes this brand’s pumpkin spice coffee an absolute hit, lies in these six 35-ounce bags. 

Best organic brew

(Image credit: The Bean Coffee Company)

The Bean Coffee Company organic pumpkin spice

Medium roast goodness

These organic coffee beans are hand-roasted and packaged in small batches to preserve their authentic flavor and freshness. This particular one checks all the boxes for anyone who loves their coffee beans whole and medium roasted with bold pumpkin notes. And its flavor is nuanced and rich, everything you’d expect from an organic coffee. No bitter aftertaste, just smooth pumpkin-spiced goodness for that early morning caffeine break.

Best pumpkin spice pod

(Image credit: SF Bay Coffee)

SF Bay Coffee pumpkin spice compostable pods

Each pod makes the world a better place

Coffee lovers can pride in the fact that their daily caffeine fix isn’t quite as bad for the planet as it could be. SF Bay has filled their coffee pods with a delicate blend of toasted cinnamon, pumpkin pie with light hints of nutmeg and vanilla, to create a delicious medium roast coffee drink. These commercially compostable pods are compatible with single-serve brewers and Keurig K-Cup brewers.

Best pumpkin pie sauce

(Image credit: Torani)

Torani pumpkin pie sauce

Squeeze, stir and indulge

Not everyone who loves pumpkin wants to drink coffee. To make everyone happy, consider Torani Pumpkin Pie Sauce. It's great for desserts, mixed drinks, teas, milkshakes, and yes, coffees. Featuring a perfect mix of cinnamon and nutmeg spices, the sauce is packed with 24 grams of sugar per serving, which is something to keep in mind whether you're looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or need to avoid. Once you establish how much of the sauce you need per serving, you can buy a separate pump for flawless operation.

Comfort in every cup

It's impressive seeing what could otherwise be a bland spice evolve into a smooth well rounded spice. The number one go-to pumpkin spice coffee flavor has to be the one from Starbucks. You can grab the ground version or stock up the K-Cup variation, and savor each cup all year.

When you want everyday hints of pumpkin in about any food imaginable, Torani Pumpkin Pie Sauce is a perfect choice. The sauce can be used to spice up your brewed coffees, lattes, desserts, and milk. The Bean Coffee Company offers 100% organic Arabica coffee beans infused with bold hints of pumpkins for everyone who loves naturally produced coffee.