The best clear mascaras: long lashes without the colour

The best clear mascaras

When most of our images of mascara are fed to us through inky-lashed, Bambi-eyed beauties in what are definitely full sets of falsies (come on advertisers, give it up) the concept of clear mascara can seem a little bit at odds with what we think a great mascara should do. But not only can the best clear mascaras give your lashes a subtle boost and a healthy sheen, there’s all sorts of other things they can do too.

First, on lashes: clear mascara separates and defines without adding colour, so if you’re in search of the ultimate no-makeup makeup, you might find one coat is enough for a hint of ‘I woke up like this’ natural glamour, and if you’re very fair, you might find it preferable to sometimes-overbearing black mascara for everyday. There’s also the added bonus that if you do get caught in an unforecast rainstorm on the way to that interview or find yourself in the middle of an unbelievably weepy movie on that first date, you won’t look like Alice Cooper’s less famous sister when the lights go up.

Elsewhere, among the most common ways to use clear mascara is as a brow gel. While we’ve been quite proud of ourselves for using this beauty shortcut for years, the brands have been getting savvy and are now selling clear mascara specifically formulated for fixing brows, some of which you’ll find in our list below. Finally, in a pinch, you can even use a clear gel mascara to fix flyaways for a sleek ‘do – who knew?

To get the most out of your mascara, you might want to curl your lashes first for extra oomph, but other than that it’s all pretty foolproof, with none of the panda eyes or other pitfalls that coloured mascaras tend to throw at us.

Clear mascara

1. Dr. Hauschka Brow & Lash Gel

Love your lashes with this botanical-packed multi-tasking gel

Best for: Fixing and defining | Volume: 6ml | Type: Brow and lash gel

Lash-conditioning botanicals
Excellent as a primer or alone
 May need some colour on brows first

One reviewer opened by saying that Dr. Hauschka Brow and Lash Gel was ‘probably the best thing to ever happen to my brows’. High praise, but it’s all backed up by a selection of small but significant virtues: the inclusion of nourishing botanicals such as neem and the appropriately named eyebright; the user-friendly design of the spoolie (that’s the brush bit, to us mortals); and of course, the lovely natural look it gives to lashes and brows. Users recommend applying alone for delicate definition, or underneath coloured mascara for flawless, non-clumpy application. 

Clear mascara

2. Estée Lauder Brow Now

This firm-hold gel ensures you’ll wow with those brows

Best for: Taming brows | Volume: 1.7ml | Type: Brow gel

Keeps hairs in place all day
Doesn’t dull colour of other brow products
You don’t get a lot in a tube 

If you’re buying a clear mascara with the sole intention of using it on your brows, it makes sense to go for something engineered for the purpose, such as Estée Lauder’s Brow Now Stay-in-Place Brow Gel. If you have naturally dark or tinted brows, one swipe may be enough for what the brand boasts is a guaranteed flake-free finish, although reviewers commented it really came into its own over a coloured brow powder or other product, where it made sure the colour stayed true, and kept hairs in place. 

Clear mascara

3. Maybelline Great Lash Mascara

A twist on a classic for those in search of a more natural look

Best for: Budgets | Volume: 13ml | Type: Lash mascara

Lovely shiny finish
Good for sensitive eyes
Not a lot of staying power 

There’s a very strong chance that you either had a tube of deep black Great Lash mascara kicking around in your makeup bag as a teenager, or that there’s still one lurking in the back of the bathroom cupboard – but have you ever tried the clear version? Its oil-free formula makes this Maybelline mascara a good bet for sensitive eyes that sometimes struggle with oil-based products, and testers found it gave lashes a lovely sheen both alone and on top of their regular coloured mascara, as well as holding the curl of lashes well. 

Clear mascara

4. Covergirl Professional Natural Lash Mascara

Nail natural lashes for a cover girl look with a difference

Best for: Hold | Volume: 10ml | Type: Lash mascara

Great holding power
Natural feathery lash look
Doesn’t hold curl too well 

While this Covergirl clear mascara is a world away from the ultra-bright Great Lash in terms of its minimal packaging design, it’s definitely not far off in terms of its fabulous water-based formula that’s great for sensitive eyes and skin. Unlike our previous pick it’s not the most adept at keeping a curl, so those with naturally poker-straight lashes might want to try something a little different, however reviewers found that its excellent hold made it a top pick for holding feathery lashes and bold brows in place throughout the day. 

Clear mascara

5. Urban Decay Mascara Resurrection

Prime and perfect with this mascara reviver

Best for: Refreshing your makeup | Volume: 8.3ml | Type: Serum

Refreshes mascaraed lashes
Can be used as a primer
Can’t be used on brows 

Full disclosure: this might not technically be a clear mascara, but according to devotees it does everything you’d expect a clear mascara to do, and then some. Engineered to bring lacklustre lashes back to their best, it can be applied before mascara as a primer if you wish, but reviewers found its real talents lie in perking up lived-in lashes. Rather than the clumpy spider leg look you might get from adding another layer of coloured mascara on top of your already worn later, users said this gel smooths, refines and refreshes dry mascara for an instantly fresher, more wide-eyed look. 

READ MORE:

For bigger, bolder lashes, check out our list of the best eyelash curlers for defining your eyes and giving your lashes the wow factor.